COmputer power
In reply to #6365 Computer Power by Anthony K. Baggaley
> 400,000 Kw/month = 400 MW/month = 13.33 MW a day This sounds more like a rate of power consumption change. `MW' is a measure of power consumption, so what is `MW per day'? Do you mean `MW-hours per day'? Then 13 MW-hr/day would be about 0.5 MW. No wonder it needs monster cooling systems! Without cooling, the temperature would probably rise toward about 500'C until it died. Of course, this discussion is assuming that we are concerned with the `supercomputer' range. What if you want something smaller? What sort of processing power can you get out of a 100W desktop computer at various TLs? I would find it quite conceivable to run a starship off a computer that, in 2 TL or so, would be considered a `pocket' computer. Based on MegaTraveller, in which TL6 is ~1950, and TL8 is ~1990, this is certainly the case. The progression in the starship computer tables seems *faster* at higher TLs, with a 2-fold increase in `maximum CP input' and 30% increase in `CP multiplier' from TL6 to TL8, but a jump of 2 TLs from TL12 to TL14 gives a 100-fold increase in `maximum CP input', and more than 100% increase in CP multiplier. Thus, if a pocket computer at TL8 is more than a match for the TL6 supercomputer, it would seem that a TL14 pocket computer should exceed the capabilities of a TL12 supercomputer by an even greater amount. This is partially borne out by the entry in the Imperial Encyclopedia, where a TL11 hand computer "provides services of a supercomputer (equivalent to Model/1 in computing power)". Now, I would expect it to be much better than that! Model/1 is the 1950's supercomputer. TL11 is post-2100 projected technology (Meson guns, gravitic structures become commonplace, Jump-2 drives, and reactionless thrusters). Nevertheless, the precedent has been set - hand computers of higher TL *can* serve as lower-TL supercomputers. In MT, a vehicle needs to cost more than ~50 MCr before it needs a Model/2. For smaller vehicles, the computer can take up a considerable amount of the power, space and cost of the total. So, just replace it with a TL11 hand computer, at 1/10000th the volume, 1/1000th the mass, and 1/900th the cost, with negligible power consumption. (MT gripe: Have you noticed that TL12 `solar cells' extract 60 times more power from sunlight than is actually present? Even TL6 cells extract 3 times more. But that's cancelled out by the much-too-small surface areas available for large ships.) - -- Tim Little